Poteau • LeFlore County
Where Can I Get Cheap Angel or Shepherd Costumes for a Church Christmas Play in Poteau?
Short answer: start at the Salvation Army Thrift Store, 400 Dewey Ave in Poteau, (918) 647-8780, and Second Chances Recovery and Resale on South Broadway, (918) 647-0612. Old bathrobes, white sheets and striped towels there make easy shepherds and angels. Walmart on N Broadway has tinsel garland for halos.
Christmas play costumes
The short answer
The cheapest angel and shepherd costumes are usually put together, not bought. The Salvation Army Thrift Store at 400 Dewey Ave in Poteau, (918) 647-8780, and Second Chances Recovery and Resale on South Broadway, (918) 647-0612, carry donated clothing and home goods like bathrobes, sheets and towels, which are most of what a nativity costume needs.
NU2U Consignment Boutique, 203 Dewey Ave, (918) 721-1606, has gently used clothing at second-hand prices. For halos, wings and trim, the Walmart Supercenter at 3108 N Broadway, 918-647-5040, is open 6 AM to 11 PM every day (closed Thanksgiving Day).
- Salvation Army Thrift Store: 400 Dewey Ave, Poteau · (918) 647-8780 · usually Tue to Sat
- Second Chances Resale: S Broadway, Poteau · (918) 647-0612 · donated clothing and home goods
- NU2U Consignment: 203 Dewey Ave, Poteau · (918) 721-1606
- Walmart Supercenter: 3108 N Broadway · 918-647-5040 · 6 AM to 11 PM, closed Nov 26
- Shepherd: robe + striped towel on the head + a cord or necktie + a stick
🛍️ Start here
Thrift and consignment shops in Poteau
The Salvation Army Thrift Store, 400 Dewey Ave, (918) 647-8780, sells donated clothing, linens and home goods at thrift prices. It is usually open Tuesday to Saturday, with shorter Saturday hours, so call before you go.
Second Chances Recovery and Resale Store on South Broadway, (918) 647-0612, sells donated clothing, decor and household goods, and the money supports its recovery programs.
NU2U Consignment Boutique, 203 Dewey Ave, (918) 721-1606, has gently used clothing and shoes at second-hand prices.
What to look for: plain bathrobes in brown, tan or striped fabric for shepherds, white or cream sheets, nightgowns and choir-style robes for angels, and big striped towels or scarves for head coverings.
🐑 Shepherds
An easy shepherd costume
Start with a bathrobe or an oversized tunic. Drape a striped hand towel or dish towel over the head and tie it on with a cord, rope or an old necktie around the forehead.
Add a belt of rope at the waist, sandals or plain brown shoes, and a walking stick or a cane for a staff. A stuffed lamb finishes it off.
😇 Angels
An easy angel costume
Fold a white flat sheet or a pillowcase (for little kids) in half, cut a hole for the head, and tie it at the waist with gold or silver ribbon or tinsel. A white T-shirt and leggings underneath keep it warm and modest.
For a halo, wrap tinsel garland around a headband or a circle of pipe cleaner. Wings can be cut from poster board and covered in white paper or tinsel, then tied on with ribbon like a backpack.
✨ Supplies
Halos, tinsel and trim
The Walmart Supercenter at 3108 N Broadway in Poteau, 918-647-5040, is open every day from 6 AM to 11 PM, and is closed on Thanksgiving Day, November 26. In the weeks before Christmas it carries tinsel garland and ribbon, along with white sheets and craft supplies like felt and pipe cleaners.
Poteau's Dollar General stores at 201 Clayton Ave and 2115 N Broadway are handy for small things like ribbon and tinsel too.
⛪ Borrow
Ask around before you buy
Many churches that do a Christmas play every year keep a box of robes, halos and head coverings. Ask your own church first, then a neighboring church, whether you can borrow theirs this year.
Parents in the cast often have an old bathrobe or white sheet at home, so a simple list of what each child needs can cover most of the costumes for free.
📅 This week & coming up
Christmas events coming up around Poteau
No events are listed for this area right now. Check the full calendar.
💡 Before you go
Costume tips
Go early
Thrift stock changes, so shop a few weeks before the play.
Buy big
Adult sizes can be belted or pinned to fit kids.
Wash first
Run thrift finds through the wash before handing them out.
Keep it warm
Layer a T-shirt and leggings under sheets and robes.
Label everything
Put each child's name inside so costumes come back.
❓ Good to know
Common questions
Where can I get cheap angel or shepherd costumes in Poteau?
Try the Salvation Army Thrift Store, 400 Dewey Ave, (918) 647-8780, Second Chances Resale on South Broadway, (918) 647-0612, and NU2U Consignment, 203 Dewey Ave, for robes, sheets and towels to make them.
How do I make a shepherd costume for a Christmas play?
Use a bathrobe or tunic, a striped towel over the head tied with a cord or necktie, a rope belt and a stick for a staff.
How do I make an angel costume cheap?
Cut a head hole in a folded white sheet or pillowcase, tie it with gold ribbon or tinsel, and make a halo from tinsel on a headband.
Where can I buy tinsel and craft supplies in Poteau?
The Walmart Supercenter at 3108 N Broadway, open 6 AM to 11 PM daily except Thanksgiving Day, and the Dollar General stores in town.
Is there a thrift store in Poteau?
Yes. The Salvation Army Thrift Store at 400 Dewey Ave and Second Chances Recovery and Resale on South Broadway.
🧭 Keep planning